The Burning Times Revisited

www.samesame.com.au
  • 33
  • 3
  • 10807

We’re putting religion under the microscope this month on Same Same, in honour of the Pope’s visit to Australia. This week Jade Starr wades through the history books, only to discover that the more things change, the more they stay the same.

There is no denying that the Catholic Church is still a very powerful organisation. They have stood the test of time in the battle to be the most believed and worshipped religion regardless of any criticism. It is also documented heavily that they played a hand in the destruction of those who opposed the Catholic doctrine throughout the centuries, which explains the lack of criticism. Those who did not follow the Catholic ideals were deemed to be witches or heretics and were then persecuted from the late 1400s to early 1700s. It has been estimated that up to nine million people lost their lives during ‘The Burning Times’ but due to a lack of evidence the exact number is accepted as closer to 50,000 to 1 million. Many of these people, predominantly women, endured unfair trials and were subsequently incarcerated or burned alive at the stake for their so-called crimes against God. Not only were Pagan people segregated, tortured and murdered but they were also robbed of their rituals and practices, which are even now still used in modern Catholicism.

The Catholic Church also has a long history of condemnation toward women; they were also a major target during the witch hunts, particularly independent and homeless women. Women have long been regarded as the nurturers, this is reflected in the goddesses of ancient Greek mythology and Pagan beliefs. Even our planet is referred to as a feminine Mother Earth. Women make up 52% of the population and frankly without them our race would have died out many moons ago. Yet they have been shunned, repressed and dengrated by this male dominated organisation. In recent times we’ve seen female priests begin to emerge, much to the chagrin of many in the Catholic hierarchy. For an organisation that preaches high morality through the word of god, they seem more like instigators of the current problems that plague humanity, through their repression and intolerance.

During the many years of slavery, the Catholic Church also stood by doing nothing until the late 1800s, using the Bible to justify their late intervention. It’s important to note that the Catholic doctrine has changed over the centuries. These changes have been influenced by politics, social and cultural change and public outcry. Things have had to change because times have changed – slavery has been reduced at least in the west, women and indigenous people now vote and have won many battles in regards to equality even though there is still a way to go. It has also been documented that the Catholic Church made a deal to turn a blind eye to Hitler and his hordes of Nazi soldiers as they decimated bloodlines of Jews. Their agreement to keep out of each others business affairs ended in 1937, when the Nazis started to become a greater threat to the church. The then Pope’s death contributed to the end of this arrangement too.

But wait there’s more!

Stereotype or not, paedophilia within the clergy has plagued the Catholic Church’s image in recent times. With advances in communication during the 1900s came allegations toward the clergy, which before the communication boom exploded were much easier to suppress. It became apparent that there had been considerable sexual abuse towards minors within the Church and that it had been covered up for many years. The Church has since paid out billions of dollars in compensation to victims of sexual abuse and has assured us that this is being stamped out internally, yet many perpetrators have not faced court or served prison time, which is as disgusting as the sex abuses that continue to surface. There seems to be a common thread of the Catholic Church taking advantage of those who are most vulnerable, be it due to their gender, sexuality, age or race. These people have been punished all in the name of god and the repression preached within the Church’s fear laden doctrine.

Whilst Catholic leaders have had to budge slightly and change their delivery of god’s morality, another minority group has vocally emerged in the last thirty years, demanding equal rights – the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community. With the Pagans hiding away practicing their magic, slavery all but a thing of the past, women and indigenous people enjoying more freedoms and child sex offenders within the clergy being exposed, it seems the Catholic Church need a new vulnerable minority group to attack, defame and rob of their civil basic rights.

Sexuality and gender expression have been one of the biggest taboos throughout the history of the Catholic Church. Sex and the guilt surrounding it has been the largest and most successful fear campaign used against society by repressive religious groups like the Catholic Church – that is unless you are having sex to create another Catholic person. As it now stands contraception, masturbation, abortion and homosexuality remain prime targets and are still deemed abhorrent and immoral, regardless of how many people are dying from overpopulation, poverty, starvation and disease.

I am still amazed by the amount of people who blindly follow a faith which promotes such blatant intolerance and contradicts itself through countless revision and interpretation of words which have no relevance to today’s world. The GLBT community are the modern witches of our time. We seem to be a massive threat to the clergy, though we’re barely mentioned in all forms of the Bible, and even when we are it’s not in a directly negative way. Just like the Pagans, women and children before us, we are vulnerable at present and are easy targets for them to rally numbers against. Current laws keep us disadvantaged – we are not equal and are often targets of humiliation and violence from parts of society. It makes us the perfect scapegoat – we are the minority who are fighting off centuries of pre-programmed negative press and are not likely to gather enough support to win.

Perhaps the Catholic Church has underestimated the GLBT community? As the world spirals out of control in the midst of hunger, financial collapse, terrorism and holy wars our humble little GLBT community continues to battle the system. Already there are significant changes happening for us and just like the others before us, if we remain vigilant and take in every small victory with pride then eventually rewards will follow.

With Sydney set to host World Youth Day, it’s shaping up to be one of the most controversial tours a Pope has ever faced. Police have bought in new laws stopping people from causing “annoyance” or “interference” to the Pope and his pilgrim parade. Expect to see water cannons, people handing out condoms, homosexual displays of affection and general disdain towards the Pope and the police for this outlandish event. After the years of child sex abuses being outed in the clergy, it seems ironic that they should hold an event with the word ‘youth’ in the title.

I will not be staying silent this week. I’m willing to face the $5,500 fine and even possible time in the lock up for protesting, which is not something a transsexual woman says lightly. Let’s all hope that Sydney turns out in huge numbers to scream a resounding “no!” to this Catholic juggernaut and our State Government.

They have tried to do this before to other minority groups but have failed. And they will fail again.

Other articles in the religion series:
God Loves You.
Constant Cravings.
Devil Or Delusion?

Photos: 1. Pope Benedict XVI, 2. Adolf Hitler, 3. A survivor of child sexual abuse at the hands of clergy, 4. The Vatican, 5. An artist’s impression of witches being burnt at the stake.

Social

  • robbie
  • GenesisInVain
  • billyg

Comments

www.samesame.com.au arrow left
3993
dreadcircus

dreadcircus said on the 15th Jul, 2008



Remembering that in the west we are expected to be far more civilized than to be burning people alive this day and age. In saying that there are still examples of witches being burned alive even as close as 2000 in some countries. I think you know as well as I honest that I am not saying we are literally being burned alive by the church but the similarities of mistreatment towards minority groups at the hands of the church is a reality and as it seems constant even though these days being set on fire has now been replaced with unequal rights based on our sexuality or gender, which still places us as an easy target.

I found this quite interesting whilst doing research for this piece.

"The words burn into my eyes like greusome headlines: 2 Women Killed By a Mob in Ghana. 1 burned alive at Verkhnesadovye. And, finally, a 55 year old woman doused with gasoline and set afire at Hammanskraael, South Africa. These people, condemned as witches, were not persecuted in the 16th or 17th century. The "unknown" 55 year old woman was murdered on 19 July, 1996.

The 20th century death toll is as ridiculous as it is long. In November, 1925 a person was shot in Germany as a suspected werewolf. One was killed for sorcery in France, 1977. And between the years 1986 and 1996, over 300 people suspected of witchcraft were killed in South Africa. Not chilled to the bone yet? Listen closely to the last entry on the Witch Killings database: Tikambai Sahu, killed by a mob, Nagpur India, 27 June, 2000."

In many countries like South Africa the definition of a witch could be derived from anything perceived as abnormal by the masses be it gay, lesbian, white, Asian, ugly, pretty or homeless. Even if its not the church directly performing the persecution it is the way they deliver their message world wide which constantly isolates us as a problem.

Honest, do you think the church would not burn us alive if the power to do so was available judging on their history?

dreadcircus

dreadcircus said on the 17th Jul, 2008

lmfao @ Hate Mongering... Are you kidding me.. these things happened, the burnings, the oppression of women, molestation of children etc .. - THAT IS HATE in its purest form!

There is documented evidence on the burning from both sides, the stories may differ slightly in regards to numbers killed but the acceptance that they occurred is there. This is an opinion piece on the Vatican's constant mistreatment of minority groups over a period of time. You think I just sat here and made this up. I'm a long time practicing pagan. I have read much on the burning from both sides. You must remember I have only a short space to express such a volume of information. During the research of this article I read many articles from both Pagan and Catholic writings mixed in with many years of reading on this subject. This story was never going to be positive towards the Catholic Church. Search google news if you want positive drivel you can find it anywhere and most of it written by Catholic people. I'm so sorry for stating a case which is rarely ever presented in the todays media and from the books and articles I have read over the years this is most accurate.

At the end of the day we are all different and don't always agree. I feel I am involved heavily in the pagan community as well as the GLBT community, both which are heavily attacked by the Vatican. I don't expect you to agree with my article, its here to create discussion and thats whats happening now. I don't see anybody questioning that these things actually occurred in regards treatment of witches, women, children and even turning a blind eye to the Nazi's... As a friend said I really should of included the Popes past scribblings also as they are just so kind to gays, lesbian and trans people.

:)

Bren

Bren said on the 19th Jul, 2008



You're missing my point, which is about the formal rules of the organisation not the personal opinions of the individual. There is an ocean of difference between these two things that ought to be acknowledged, by opponents and proponents of current Catholicism, because it is rules, not opinions, that formally define what Catholicism is. The Church is not a democracy.

I'm a gay ex-Catholic. As well as "choosing to be gay", I do not believe in the Catholic God. Both of these things are against Catholic rules. So I'm not just "not a Catholic", I cannot be a Catholic because my beliefs are incompatible with Catholic rules (no matter how hard I might try to "reconcile" and justify them).

To put it another way: When you become a member of an organisation, you do your best to abide by its rules. If you willingly and unrepentantly break the rules, your membership is compromised. The Catholic Church is no different. Conformity to official doctrine is a requirement of membership. Wanna be a Catholic? Play by the rules.



Alas, sometimes truth is shocking.

Personally, as a gay person, I think being labelled "objectively disordered" and "more or less ordered towards an intrinsic moral evil" by the wealthy powerful chairman of an all-male celibate committee who, for decades, have shielded pedophiles in their ranks, is offensive.



That you can't distinguish between legitimate criticism of the hierarchy versus actual bigotry? Very sad indeed, yes. Interesting, isn't it?
[COLOR=White].

DeepBlueDreamer

DeepBlueDreamer said on the 20th Jul, 2008

I'll say the same thing I said to dreadcircus - talk to a gay catholic, because they do believe they fit into the equation.

And its actually quite insulting to say that gay catholic is a contradiction in terms. I actually find all of this quite sad. As a supposed community, you'd think we'd be a little more accepting and understanding. But all I am really seeing here is bigotry and bias basically justified by they did it to us so its ok for us to do it back to them.

Interesting isn't it?

Any community has the right to protest against institutions that discriminate against them. And the catholic church is such an institute. The fact that some members of our community belongs to, or are loyal to other such institutions, I think is best handles and discussed with understanding from both sides.

I think people of Catholic faith should understand the anger and the frustration of the community and perhaps even feeling betrayed by their own. The preaching from the leadership of the catholic church is clear and is clearly unacceptable. The anger and frustration is understandable.

Saying that, I think we also should learn to acknowledge that people borne in to a community of followers of a faith has very strong bonds with the beliefs as well as to the people of that community. It would be naive to assume that arguments about beliefs and contradictions on a public forum can change that. Instead, I think it would be far more productive to discuss ways of changing the the way church is looking at the community.

Besides, we are all law abiding citizens, but that doesn't mean that we can't enjoy a good dance party? Same way I think Gay Catholics are faithful to their faith...and enjoy sex. :)

Moreover, i think the church will change with pressure from the Gays in the church...it's happening now in the Anglican church...well, also because of empty seats during mass...progressive laws....etc.