News and Current Affairs

Elton John - art vs porn.

View Poll Results: What do you think of Nan Goldin's picture?
Art 3 75.00%
Kiddy Porn 1 25.00%
Voters: 4. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
  Tools
Christian Taylor +

has just logged into Same Same after many months and is blown away at the facelift!

Christian Taylor's Avatar
Joined
Oct 2006
Times thanked
20
Posts
3,684
Default Elton John - art vs porn.
So, Elton's found himself at the centre of child porn allegations all because some conservative gallery employee decided to sexualise what is essentially a pretty innocent piece of art.

Here's the piece in question. What do you think? Art or porn?
alison87 +

feeling amazing!

alison87's Avatar
Joined
Jan 2007
Times thanked
0
Posts
334
Default
Neither. Looks like a crappy family photo parents use to embarass their kids when they grow up.
House music makes me moist.

BOING!!!
Asherbella +

Follow your passions, enrich your heart, embrace peace - make the shadows depart

Asherbella's Avatar
Joined
Aug 2008
Times thanked
601
Posts
10,131
Default
Traditionally belly dancing has been viewed as a Middle-Eastern woman's 'coming of age' ceremony - a kind of 'entry into womanhood'. In Arab/Turkish culture it is 'haram' or 'surdun' (not proper) for a child to even attempt belly-dancing. The artwork is inappropriately titled & culturally ignorant/offensive to those that know better, but as an image the photo is a 'life in motion' shot, not necessarily kiddie porn. Only a paedophile would look at this shot & become aroused. Those that charge this shot as having a pedo element would only do so with a subconcious 'takes one to know one' mentality.....
The two infants in the shot are left to interact seemingly unassisted, albeit dressed in 'trashy' clothes or not at all. You can load any meaning that's conveniently subversive upon this shot if you've got a mind that's less than unsavoury or wish it to be corrupting should you want it to be......
Asherbella +

Follow your passions, enrich your heart, embrace peace - make the shadows depart

Asherbella's Avatar
Joined
Aug 2008
Times thanked
601
Posts
10,131
Default
What do other posters think?
jimmy_ +

not

jimmy_'s Avatar
Joined
Dec 2008
Times thanked
9
Posts
2,579
Default
Gotta agree with Alison. It's neither!
Reply

Previous Thread  |  Next Thread

Posting Rules

+
    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts