Burns Takes On Channel Nine

www.samesame.com.au
  • 233
  • 7
  • 5799

Gary Burns has announced that he’s lodged a complaint with the NSW Anti-Discrimination Board against Channel Nine’s The Footy Show.

The complaint refers to a sketch that aired earlier this month, where footy players Andrew and Matthew Johns reflect on their childhood, growing up with a fictitious gay sibling, Elton Johns.

The sketch flashes back to childhood moments where Andrew and Matthew are playing footy, while Elton is described as ‘unco-ordinated’ and a ‘hazard’, dressed in camp sunglasses and an orange feather boa. At one point the father of the boys takes young Elton back to the hospital where he was born and asks for a refund, saying that the boy is ‘faulty’. Another moment sees the father talk about how he thinks Elton was switched at birth, because of his homosexuality. Photos also depict young Elton kissing a pig, and recoiling from breast feeding as an infant.

Gary Burns told SX that the sketch was “a very clear-cut case of anti-gay vilification” and that the humour “clearly portrays homosexual men as objects of ridicule.” Burns said that if the jokes were made against Jews, Aboriginals or Asian people then they’d never make it on TV.

Matthew Johns has since been stood down indefinitely from his hosting role on the Nine Network program after becoming embroiled in a group sex scandal, kicked off by an episode of ABC’s Four Corners. Johns has also lost his position on the Melbourne Storm coaching staff.

“I am asking for a full page apology in the pages of SX at the moment,” Burns told Same Same. “I will also be seeking a ‘on air’ apology on the footy show from its presenters. Gay footballer Ian Roberts phoned me yesterday offering his support.”

Burns told Same Same that jokes like these can drive gay teenagers to suicide.

“Pernicious comments like these question the self worth in many gay teenagers because of issues of low self-esteem when dealing with their own sexuality [and] coming out… Gay teenagers are vulnerable and commentary suggesting gay men are sick or faulty is unlawful homosexuality vilification. It’s not acceptable to paint homosexuals as products of ridicule anymore.”

Burns is still pushing ahead with legal action against Jeff Kennett after her refused to apologise for comments he made linking paedophilia and homosexuality.

Watch the clip below. Do you think it’s offensive? Vote here.

Social

  • Gay Activist
  • akkaz
  • Lawre7
  • chezcaliente
  • jayboy
  • peter1009
  • dylan3rd

Comments

www.samesame.com.au arrow left
9460
jordan

jordan said on the 1st Jun, 2009

Again Zebra, I would invite you to read up on a study called 'Semantics'. I really think it would help you understand, it would also help you formulate a rebuttal to me other than "I disagree".

:)

You keeping taking this argument out of context by trying to compare this to Will and Grace and Big Gay Al. They're not relevant because they're not the same context and they don't convey the same meaning - they're not the same social message. Again, read about Semantics.

Censorship is an interesting angle. But again, I would ask you to keep the context relevant in this debate, because it's all about context.

We have the (assumed right) to free speech. If you want to say something, you can, without fear that authorities will arrest you. Let's be clear, that is actually what free speech is by definition.

In television and in the media they have a responsibilities and standards governed by legislation because smart people have determined that the right to free speech, such as giving your opinion at a family BBQ that you think all Jews should have been gassed and saying it on national TV in prime time are two very different things. The context is important.

We, as a society have said that you cannot abuse the power to communicate. What makes this particularly pathetic, is that they don't come out and just say "We don't like gays" - Because they can't say this (due to those pesky laws preventing people in power from abusing it against weaker people in society) they disguise what is absolute pure homophobia as a joke so then if anyone says anything they can say "it was just a joke".

I would ask you this. If they had actually just said verbatim "Aboriginals were a mistake of evolution. They shouldn't have been born." Do you think thats ok? Anyone reasonable would say 'no'. So why is it different just because it's about gay people and is presented as a joke?

shaynesydney

shaynesydney said on the 2nd Jun, 2009

You always exaggerate to strengthen your victim status.

By far the majority of comments I've read are bagging the footy show or highlighting that it was just a joke.

ZOMG., it's no wonder you're ashamed to show your face, you're SUCH a liar:

"I also see gays expecting every slight against them be treated as a national emergency and getting away with behaviour no straight person would, all the while abusing, vilifying, and lying about others. If the gay community wants to talk about hatred, intolerance, inequaility, and 'typing their bile' as 'voiced reason' put it, they should look at themselves first. "
"lighten up, get over it, get on with life."
"Mr Burns is obviously too sensitive and should get a life."
"We live in a Democracy, so why do gays think they have the right to FORCE people to be tolerant of the life style, some people agree with the gay life while others find it totally disgusting, what the gay community forget is that people are ALLOWED to think what they do is wrong."
"Some people should shut the hell up, and stop creating "target groups" and crying "poor us/me/them" every time something goes against them. Whatever happened to "sticks and stones"?????"
"when is all this political correctness going to stop. People need to lighten up.
blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah"
"some people will cry about anything to get their name into the papers. if a person is a gay or one of the many other minorities that we have in socitiety nowadays, expect to be mocked or ridiculed sometimes. just learn to get over it."
"But it is OK for Gays to dress up as Nuns and Priests during the Gay Mardi Gras and Sleaze Ball. Am I the only one to see a double standard here?"
"So it's okay for gays to go around calling everyone who doesn't think they're the greatest thing since sliced bread bigots by poking fun at gays should bring legal sanction?"
"Seems to me that you cant say or do anything these days with out some thin skinned righteous screaming racism or discrimination. I'm sick of it."
"Well it's been a while since gays have had something to whinge or protest about.... get a life!"

...and so on and - and then there's all the shit that was to disgusting to publish. At least we know where u get ur ideas from, zebby.

zebra-stripes

zebra-stripes said on the 2nd Jun, 2009

ZOMG., it's no wonder you're ashamed to show your face, you're SUCH a liar:

"I also see gays expecting every slight against them be treated as a national emergency and getting away with behaviour no straight person would, all the while abusing, vilifying, and lying about others. If the gay community wants to talk about hatred, intolerance, inequaility, and 'typing their bile' as 'voiced reason' put it, they should look at themselves first. "
"lighten up, get over it, get on with life."
"Mr Burns is obviously too sensitive and should get a life."
"We live in a Democracy, so why do gays think they have the right to FORCE people to be tolerant of the life style, some people agree with the gay life while others find it totally disgusting, what the gay community forget is that people are ALLOWED to think what they do is wrong."
"Some people should shut the hell up, and stop creating "target groups" and crying "poor us/me/them" every time something goes against them. Whatever happened to "sticks and stones"?????"
"when is all this political correctness going to stop. People need to lighten up.
blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah"
"some people will cry about anything to get their name into the papers. if a person is a gay or one of the many other minorities that we have in socitiety nowadays, expect to be mocked or ridiculed sometimes. just learn to get over it."
"But it is OK for Gays to dress up as Nuns and Priests during the Gay Mardi Gras and Sleaze Ball. Am I the only one to see a double standard here?"
"So it's okay for gays to go around calling everyone who doesn't think they're the greatest thing since sliced bread bigots by poking fun at gays should bring legal sanction?"
"Seems to me that you cant say or do anything these days with out some thin skinned righteous screaming racism or discrimination. I'm sick of it."
"Well it's been a while since gays have had something to whinge or protest about.... get a life!"

...and so on and - and then there's all the shit that was to disgusting to publish. At least we know where u get ur ideas from, zebby.



Those comments aren't hateful.



This simply isn't the case looking at the quotes you yourself have attempted to single out.

They simply aren't saying hateful things about being gay. That "gays are inferior and 'faulty' ".

You're exaggerating.

There are 132 more comments. View them all