2AM Shutdown Proposed ForQueensland

www.samesame.com.au
  • 65
  • 4
  • 1838

Frustration is rife among the clubbing and music community following a proposal from the Queensland Police Union that would enforce a 2am club lockdown throughout Queensland. With excessive cases of drunken behaviour and violence on our streets cited as the reasons for this movement in protecting Queensland club-goers and emergency service workers, the proposal is especially focused towards clubbing hotspots, including Brisbane’s Fortitude Valley, parts of the Brisbane CBD, Gold Coast’s Surfers Paradise and parts of the Sunshine Coast. Under the proposal, entire entertainment districts would be closed from 2am with suburban pubs, clubs and hotels banned from trading after midnight.

QPU General President Ian Levers provocatively suggested that “a 2am shutdown would be more effective than Queensland’s controversial 3am lockout and proposed glass bans. Let’s stop the chaos on our streets. We can see no good reason to continue drinking until 5am in the morning. Most of the USA and Europe have 2am closing times and the very same problems are currently being experienced in New South Wales and Victoria. Let’s follow the trend.” Most astonishing is Lord Mayor Campbell Newman’s sudden backflip on the matter. Previously in favour of regulated late night trading, the Lord Mayor now says “on the basis of the advice I have received, I have to say today that we need to get behind the things [the unions] are talking about. I’m here out of desperation.”

Queensland’s mainstream media are running wild with the proposed action, inviting the community to contribute their thoughts on the issue. Elders, schoolmarms and preachers from as far flung as Beenleigh to Sherwood, Redcliffe and Caboolture – the very people who most probably don’t even venture outside of their front door beyond 8pm on the weekend – are all jumping onboard the “say no to violence and intoxication” bandwagon with their antiquated opinions. The danger here is that an out-of-touch contingent will ignore the heart of the reasons for the problems in the first place – which arguably, can be traced back to the 3am lockout. Since its inception in 2005, it has only caused intense frustration and havoc on our streets as crowds of intoxicated revelers are locked out of venues, with a poor public transport system and limited taxis keeping them concentrated in the one area.

The deadline of Friday October 23 has passed where opinions and submissions about Alcohol were sought from the community for the Government-driven Valley Liquor Accord Patron Survey. With this most recent and startling announcement, the late night hospitality industry especially are up in arms at the looming possibility that their jobs may be on the immediate front line.

The rest of Australia had better watch out, as you could be next.

Social

  • MariusMS
  • Xiphias-Gladius
  • hazyinseptember
  • kylierose

Comments

www.samesame.com.au arrow left
12633
Mildly Amused

Mildly Amused said on the 4th Nov, 2009



Ah well, you see, that's the problem - prohibition does not work and has never worked. Excessive alcohol use is a cutural problem in Australia that will take generations to change. The solution is in the home and it starts with the parents.

There have been two local example whereby probibition has failed - first, the tax hike on ready to drink products (RTDs). Initially it created a decline in RTD sales however there was a spike in spirit sales - essentially it created a product shift in consumption patterns. Over time, RTD sales have returned to pre tax levels. So, that didn't work (although the govt collects more tax).

Secondly, the 3am lockout - I don't really need to explain how successful that has been; not! So; there are two recent and local examples of where prohibition has failed despite that "noise" created by the pollies claiming they're on the case!

On the flip side, deregulation of licencing laws is not a short term answer either. The UK (which has a similar drinking culture to Australia) deregulated a couple of years ago - basically with no minimum trading hours i.e. generally pubs/clubs could open and close when they liked. Unfortunately, the anti social issues have not decreased and have in fact increased in some areas. The UK is now looking at reintroducing regulation surrounding the sale and consumption of alcohol.

However, when you hop accross the Channel into Europe, in most EU countries the sale and consumption of alcohol is fairly relaxed and in most cases those countries do not experience the same level of problems caused by alcohol as we do in Australia (and the UK). If you are fortunate to travel to those countries, the only drunk people you see on the streets are usually the tourists!

That's why this is a cutural problem for SE Qld (and indeed for the remainder of Australia) and will take a long time to fix. Parents need to educate their kids (and lead by example) on the excessive use of alcohol. We have to break down what has become an acceptable "binge drinking" cuture in order to address this problem.

Don't get we wrong, I like most people like to have a drink or two with friends - we just need to teach our young people that it's ok to not have to get hammered and it's cool to drink in a responsible manner i.e. you don't have to drink yourself under the table to show that you're a man, girl (or whatever).

So that's why I say prohibition does not work!

Time for me to climb down from my soap box and sip (and I mean sip) another Martini (tonight)!

perkin

perkin said on the 4th Nov, 2009

Matt may like to think of himself as a Devil's Advocate, stirring the pot provoking debate and opinion; however Matt's way of presenting his arguments leaves a little to be desired if that is indeed his modus operandi
I agree with Mildly Amused about Europe. I was in Copenhagen in July and was gobsmacked to see the alcohol consumption - particularly outside a 7-11 at 08:30 in the morning! However, alcohol is freely available and in many countries it is taxed accordingly (Sweden for instance - ouch!). Perhaps it does instill something of way of drinking socially - not to excess but for enjoyment?
Full prohibition is an ineffective method of controlling behaviour. Earlier closing times will increase, not decrease, alcohol abuse. (Older people will have "fond" memories of the "six o'clock swill" from the dark days of licensing laws.)
As with anything - food, alcohol, coffee, tea, chocolate, sun exposure, recreational drugs, casual sex, high speed driving - moderation is the key. Excessive amounts of anything will cause problems. Education is the key and developing a culture that promotes acceptable living standards and quality of life will lead to a better outcome.
And, finally, I don't think we can blame our Celtic background for being such bad drunks - the Irish are like the Australians, they love to drink (and my god, so do the Danes....tangential thought - why is it that the Danes are the most gorgeous looking people in the world when they smoke like chimneys, eat a diet that is high in saturated fats, dairy and salt (oh god...the salt!!) and drink like fishes?)...I didn't experience any aspects of "bad" drunkenness and antisocial behaviour in any part of Ireland or Scotland for that matter.
The debate cannot be handed over to irrational opinions and solutions. The Government is prone to kneejerk reactions because that is what common media tell the uniformed public who in turn yap loudly at their political representatives. If we want informed debate, then we have to yap not necessarily louder - just longer and more intelligently.

kylierose

kylierose said on the 4th Nov, 2009

i know for a fact that violence is not directly linked to the consumption of alcohol, afterhours, on the weekends. :confused: why? :confused: because last week on the way to work i saw two people in work uniforms laying into someone at a bus stop. this was at 6.30am in the city, in broad daylight.

and i've seen plenty of altercations in the valley mall where alcohol was not involved. it's the nature of putting all those people in the one place, at the one time that has caused these issues to arise. bad planning on city council and state government's part in the idealistic days of labour government's charge in the late 90's.

and i also know that people who are violent will be violent, regardless of how much they've had to drink. prohibiting the sale of alcohol, demanding that venues close at 2am and even earlier in some locations will only exacerbate a problem that i see as linked directly to the 3am lockout.

it's a classic case of the neo-conservative government and the police union attempting to create a quick fix to a problem they have helped create in the first place. band-aid solutions will mean that the problems will only get worse before some better action is taken. and by better, i mean with more planning, increased resources for transport and policing while all those people spill out onto the streets at 2am.

the valley can be a really unsafe place to be for even the most street-smart among us. but i foresee the results of this attempt to curb violence in venues will be a sharp increase in attacks that may not involve glassings, but most certainly involve hurting and maiming on a wider, more random scale.

this is NOT a solution, it is actually going to generate more problems in the long, and the short term

/end rant/